Arming Teachers Isn’t The Answer

Posted on October 12, 2015 by

I’ve been deeply, deeply rattled by the most recent mass shooting in Oregon.  Not just because I’m a mom, and I mourn the inconceivable loss of the children. Not just because I’m a writer, and mourn the loss of the creative writing teacher. And not just because I’m a human, and mourn the violence and tragedy of anyone killed at the hands of another.

I’m utterly devastated because I’m a classroom teacher, and I’m tired of worrying if this will happen to me. I’m a junior high school teacher, concentrating on serving students with the best education I can. I’m focused on watching developing minds bloom, and creating lessons to capture their attention and engage their minds. I’m intent on offering the very best of me every single minute of my work day. My intention is to help make the world a better place by teaching kids to be confident, kind, and compassionate humans.

I’m not focused on protecting them from a mass shooter – but now, I feel like I need to start paying attention.

I’ve made it no secret how I feel about guns and violence. I’ve written about every mass shooting in schools since I started this blog. I’ve shared my fears and my anger over and over, both here and on social media.

gun violence

I’ve likely lost some friends because of it, too. My voice becomes too loud for some when they have a fundamental disagreement with what its saying.

I’m sorry it has to end that way, but honestly, I’m OK with it.

Last spring, I wrote about what a school lockdown really feels like. My first-person narrative has been reprinted in the Huffington Post, on Bonbon Break, and many other websites. It has been shared hundreds of times, and on September 1, even turned into a podcast interview for Ten too Twenty Parenting.

And then last week, fifteen minutes before I was instructed to huddle once again on the floor of my classroom, I saw the news alert about the Umpqua Community College. My shoulders slumped, my jaw dropped, and I felt the tears coming. Not again. NOT AGAIN!

The bell rang and my students tumbled into the classroom. We did the safety drill. We talked about why we were doing it. We discussed the reality of the world, and how scary it was that people with guns were coming to schools to hurt students and teachers.

No teacher wants to have those conversations with their students. No parent wants to know their child is in lockdown.

schools and guns

Out of the wake of any tragedy, the media frenzy commences. The people begin talking, politicians begin sharing, and tempers flare. One side says this, the other that. Friends realize how different they might be. Families realize they don’t agree.

Once again, before the crime scene tape has been renewed, the media headlines begin, shouting out solutions. Over and over again, my temper rises as the default solution escapes from the lips of those who don’t set foot in classrooms: Arm the teachers. Teach them to kill.

As my anger escalates, the words escape me – it is that unimaginable to ask me, a mother, wife and 25-year teaching veteran, to arm myself before I walk into the classroom to serve my students.

There has got to be a more sensible solution.

I’m sharing this with you to start a dialogue. Gun violence is a multi-faceted issue, of that I am sure. I know we all want the same outcome: we want the killing to stop. But arming teachers isn’t the answer. It shouldn’t even be on the table.

I’d love for you to read my weekly post for The Educator’s Room – I’m talking about Gun Violence: An Educator’s New Normal? If you don’t understand my stand against arming teachers, listen to their conversations. Talk to your child’s school administration. Think about your favorite teacher from the past – is it really their job to be the first responder to an armed shooter? Shouldn’t we, couldn’t we, come up with a better answer?

One thing I know for sure – arming teachers isn’t the right one.

I welcome your comments that enable a discussion about solutions – if you have hate and vitriol to spew, do it somewhere else.

Remember, I’m a teacher.

p.s. – In the time since I wrote this and it was published, there have been TWO more school shootings – one in Arizona, and one in Texas. This teacher mom demands ACTION!
photo credit: Blackstar Arms via photopin (license)
photo credit: Caution: School Crossing via photopin (license)

guns in schools

Jennifer Wolfe

Jennifer Wolfe, a writer-teacher-mom, is dedicated to finding the extraordinary in the ordinary moments of life by thinking deeply, loving fiercely, and teaching audaciously. Jennifer is a Google Certified Educator, Hyperdoc fanatic, and a voracious reader. Read her stories on her blog, mamawolfe, and grab free copies of her teaching and parenting resources.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:
TwitterFacebookLinkedInPinterestGoogle PlusYelp

Comments: 8

  • Shahzad

    November 29, 2023

    “Your poignant reflections on the devastating impact of mass shootings in schools resonate deeply. As an experienced teacher, your focus on nurturing young minds clashes with the grim reality of lockdown drills. Arming teachers, a debated solution, lacks sensibility. Thank you for initiating this crucial dialogue on a complex issue.”

  • Marina Delgado

    October 20, 2015

    I’m a secondary victim of gun violence, my brother was murdered almost 12 years ago. It saddens me that angry, scared, mistrusting gun owners would rather continue to spout talking points from the NRA rather than having an open and honest dialogue about what gun safety really means. It certainly DOES NOT mean arming an entire country. If people really cared about stopping what’s happening we would be trying any and all avenues to make the acquisition of guns the safest it could possibly be. Unfortunately, some won’t even entertain the smallest notion of that. Sad, just sad.
    Marina Delgado recently posted…Take a MomentMy Profile

    • Jennifer Wolfe

      October 20, 2015

      Marina, thank you for your touching comment. I agree with you completely. I disagree so strongly with the NRA and the idea of fear they promote- and to think that we will just keep piling more and more guns I to our society is a solution? I’m so sorry to know about the tragedy you’ve lived through, and glad that we are able to connect over this important issue.

  • Alex

    October 16, 2015

    As a country, you only have two options. You ban firearms completely, or you increase security in schools. Obviously you can’t arm teachers. That’s a ridiculous concept, I completely agree. But if you can’t ban firearms (and it certainly doesn’t look like America is going to reach that point any time soon) increasing security is your only option. It should be noted even if you did ban firearms in the country the problem would not be resolved. But it would certainly be a start.

  • My Inner Chick

    October 12, 2015

    –I thought after Sandy Hook, something would be done.

    Nothing was done. WHY? WHYYYY?

    Do they actually want our schools
    to be armed w/ guns? Ridiculous. Outrageous. It sounds like something Donald Trump might say. STUPID>

    I watched a conversation recently from a man in Australia that goes something like this—- “After our mass shooting, our government said, NO MORE GUNS…and we were like, Yeah, that makes sense….After your mass shootings, you all say F*ck You.”

    What is wrong with this country? I’m embarrassed by this attitude.
    My Inner Chick recently posted…here is the deepest secret (a story of domestic abuse)My Profile

    • Jennifer Wolfe

      October 13, 2015

      The thought that the NRA has such power is frightening. The idea that human life has such little value over guns is disgusting. The idea that teachers should be armed is ridiculous. And pastors? And store clerks? And gas station attendants and pilots and the list goes on and on. More guns will not solve this problem. Thank you so much for your comment, Kim. I see we are thinking the same way. ❤️

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    CommentLuv badge